Unearthed Evidence — Factual. Fearless. True Crime.
🧾 Have a case you want us to cover? Request it here
Homicide

Nathan Brooks and the Night Bellaire Lost Halloween

📅 1995-09-30 📍 Bellaire, Ohio, United States

Timeline of Events

Click any date to view the full description.

1995 (early)

Warning Signs

September 29, 1995

Mother Returns Home

Late September 30, 1995

Ryan Goes Out

September 30, 1995

Double Murder

Early October 1, 1995

Brother Called Home

Early October 1, 1995

Bodies Discovered

October 1, 1995

Arrest of Nathan Brooks

October 1995

Community Response

October 1996

Trial and Conviction

October 27, 1996

Incarceration Begins

August 2025

Parole Hearing Scheduled

November 2025

Parole Hearing Held

December 2025

Parole Decision Announced